Thinkbox LogoThinkbox
Media Mix Navigator: There are no guarantees, but there is guidance

Media Mix Navigator: There are no guarantees, but there is guidance

Posted on: July 18, 2023
Matt Hill

Research & Planning Director, Thinkbox


In turbulent times, businesses become more risk averse. So it’s a good moment to look at how different media channels offer hugely variable returns

Everyone’s worried about the economic outlook, and advertisers are no different. They want visibility and reassurance that their media investments will deliver. Rolling the dice might be an option during the very best of times. In these worst of times we want the safest bets possible.

Although guarantees aren’t available, guidance is. It’s in this context that we have just overhauled and updated the vast econometric data that sits behind the Media Mix Navigator, our free media mix allocation tool.

The tool gives an idea of the optimal media plan and the likely return you should expect given the context of your specific business. It’s designed for those without their own econometric analysis, or as a benchmarking device for those with.

It was first launched in 2019 (then called the Demand Generator). But a lot has happened since then, and it needed to be brought up to date. It now covers 2018 to 2021, with econometric data from Mediacom, Wavemaker, Gain Theory, and Mindshare for 52 brands across 14 product categories and 10 media channels collectively representing some £2.2 billion in ad spend.

So what does the new data tell us? Three main things…


Some changes in short-term ROI

Due to the slight differences between the make-up of the brands included within the databank we used back in 2019 and the one in play now, precise comparisons aren’t possible. Small movements in effectiveness should be interpreted as sample effects rather than effectiveness shifts. But the data does give a steer on any significant changes in short-term effectiveness.

The first impression is that all channels tend to perform along the equilibrium of % spend and % short-term sales. But remember this is a databank of brands that use econometric modelling to help them optimise their spend, so it’s unsurprising that the channels are being ‘maxed out’. Over time the econometric models have helped the advertisers to find the optimum levels of investment in each channel to drive the maximum total return.

The principle finding when comparing channel performance for the 2018-21 databank with the 2016-19 databank is that, despite shifts in media consumption, there is very little movement in the relative media performance for short-term return (the bigger dots compared with the little ones).

Linear TV remains top right by some distance, accounting for 47% of return from 48% of spend. Audio, online display, OOH, and BVOD remain static in terms of short-term effectiveness.

The only three notable movers across the two periods are search, print & social media advertising.

Previously, search was highly efficient, generating 20% of return from 13% of spend. However, due to inflation in PPC search cost the efficiency of search has dropped to a more comparable level with the other channels (13% of return from 14% of spend).

Spend on print advertising has dropped between the two periods down from 11% to 8%, but % of sales has only declined from 11% to 9%, moving it up the efficiency curve. Social advertising has increased in % budget from 4% to 7%, with % sales following suit.

In terms of short-term ROI, audio is the one channel that looks under-invested in, accounting for 9% of sales from only 6% of spend.

There are safer waters to swim in

The two measures that financial teams care about the most when assessing a potential investment are return and risk. As we navigate uncertain times, the focus on the risk of any given investment will increase.

This chart displays the latest data on the variability of returns by channel. Low variability means that this channel is more likely to return a predictable ROI (less risky), whilst high ROI variability means the opposite (riskier).

It’s worth noting that high variability works both ways: there’s the possibility of achieving a much higher than average ROI, as well as a much lower one. Using this data can help planners and CMOs discuss their attitudes to risk for a given media plan and adjust accordingly.

So the question is what matters more: higher confidence in a certain result, or the potential for a higher return with the risk it may backfire?

Effectiveness is transformed when we include sustained effects

The Media Mix Navigator now has a higher granularity of data available on how long-term effects differ by product category.

The new data shows that automotive campaigns have the highest sustained effects (unsurprisingly). On average the long-term multiplier for an automotive brand is 2.58 (i.e. if your short-term return – 0-3 months post campaign – is £1 million then during the subsequent 2.75 years, this campaign will generate a further £2.58 million in sales).

Online retail also delivers a high long-term multiplier of 1.63, telecoms is next at 1.40, finance follows with 1.24, then retail at 1.21, with FMCG having the lowest multiplier at 0.88.

If these substantial sustained effects are considered when assessing channel performance it changes the picture.

Because TV, by some way, has the highest long-term multiplier, across the entire dataset it produces by far the biggest increase in total returns, accounting for 61% of all sales with its 48% of spend. Generic search shrinks, accounting for 8% of total returns for 14% of spend. Audio, which looked under-invested in when looked at in the short-term looks more like it gets the right level of investment when its sustained impact is included.

In summary

So the new databank behind the updated Media Mix Navigator and the guidance it provides hopefully offer advertisers some reassurance as we head towards 2023. It will help them make the evidence-based business case for continued investment in advertising, and how to mitigate risk, while costs come under even greater scrutiny.

This article first appeared on Media Leader

Subscribe today to receive the latest news in your inbox

We ask for your details so we can send you things we think you'll find most relevant and useful. We will never sell your data and we promise to keep your details safe and secure.