In summary
‘Profit Ability 2: The new business case for advertising’ shows how advertising is a profitable driver of business growth. The study is vital in understanding the nuances of different channels and sectors. It can help build your case that advertising (for your sector) is money well spent, as well as provide the expected timescale of returns. It can help planners to right-size their media investment by channel and by timeframe.
And all its data helps fuel the Media Mix Navigator, the free tool that allows you to explore different planning scenarios to define the optimum media mix for your business. The tool can be used in a variety of situations, such as a starting point for budget allocation and payback when you don’t have access to specific econometrics; to show the impact on business outcomes of adding a new channel; or to explore the impact of different risk tolerances.
The Headlines
- Advertising pays back. Average short-term profit ROI is £1.87 per £1 invested. When sustained effects are included, this rises to £4.11.
- TV is the biggest driver of advertising-generated profit. Linear TV + BVOD account for 54.7% of full advertising-generated profit, with an average full profit ROI of £5.61 per £1 spent.
- Linear TV has the highest weekly saturation point. Based on immediate payback, Linear TV hits saturation at around £330,000 per week on average.
- Immediate payback is not exclusive to “performance” media. Generic PPC is the largest driver of immediate payback (30.5%), but Linear TV (20.5%) is second, followed by Paid Social (15.1%), Audio (8.6%) and BVOD (7.3%).
- Profitability varies by sector. Advertising’s full profit ROI differs by category, reflecting differences in margins, product value, customer behaviour and business models.
- Advertising effectiveness shifts post-Covid have been incremental. Advertising effectiveness has shifted gradually, but the fundamentals of profitable advertising investment remain strong.
Background
Brexit, Covid, climate doom, wars, cost of living crises, social media … human context and behaviour has transformed in recent years. The need for an up to date, robust view of the role for advertising investment – and whether it has been affected – was vital.
So we commissioned ‘Profit Ability 2: The new business case for advertising’ from Ebiquity, EssenceMediacom, Gain Theory, Mindshare, and Wavemaker UK to provide the first post-Covid analysis of advertising’s financial impact.
The biggest ever econometric meta-analysis of the drivers of advertising effectiveness, it shows how and why advertising is a profitable driver of business growth, and proves that all forms of advertising pay back, especially when their sustained effects are measured.
Its data also powers the Media Mix Navigator - a tool that allows advertisers and planners to evaluate the optimal media mix and return on investment tailored to their specific business.
Methodology
Collectively, Ebiquity, EssenceMediacom, Gain Theory, Mindshare, and Wavemaker UK collated econometric analyses from 141 brands, covering £1.8 billion of media spend.
To provide a true post-Covid understanding of performance, the databank features campaigns from 2021 – 2023 (where only the most recent 52 weeks available for each brand was used).
By definition, the database is a benchmark of advertisers with the means to econometrically analyse their advertising’s performance. Whilst not representative of the whole advertising economy (as it does not include the long-tail of advertisers who don’t do market mix modelling, or use media agency partners) the Profit Ability 2 dataset does provide a valid read on mainstream ‘big brand’ performance.
This study also explored the pre- and post-Covid effects. 53 brands from the wider dataset were matched where like-for-like market mix modelling analysis was available across both pre- and post-pandemic time periods, allowing us to investigate how effectiveness has changed since 2018-2019.
In total, 14 business sectors are represented in the dataset, where seven have the required brand count of nine brands to be reported individually. The data also covers ten media channels:
- Audio: all forms of audio advertising including linear radio, digital radio and podcasts
- BVOD: Video on Demand on broadcaster platforms
- Cinema: On screen advertising in cinemas
- Generic PPC: Pay per click search advertising on non-branded keywords
- Linear TV: Broadcast TV advertising
- Online Display: All formats of display advertising
- Online Video: All formats of online video pre/mid/post roll including YouTube
- Out of Home: Digital and static posters in all environments
- Paid Social: All advertising within social platforms including in-feed video
- Print: All advertising within newspapers & magazines. Digital spend with newsbrands etc. included in Online Display
Direct mail and SEO are not included, as the data from the 141 brands did not have a robust volume of effectiveness data for these two channels. Similarly, brand search and affiliates are excluded, as these are considered pure ‘fulfilment’ media which facilitate a sale but do not generate demand for a brand.
- Profit Volume and Profit ROI were the two business outcomes used to measure the effectiveness of the channels:
- Profit Volume is the incremental contribution of advertising to business profit based on unit sales, revenue contribution, profit margin and/or lifetime value.
- Profit ROI is the ratio between profit volume and advertising spend (ROI = profit volume / media spend where 1 = breakeven).
Profit Ability 2 also analysed the profit generated by advertising at different stages as its effects build over time. It examined four speeds of payback:
- Immediate payback – within one week
- Short-term payback – up to 13 weeks – i.e. includes immediate payback
- Sustained payback – week 14 through to 24 months
- Full payback – total payback 0-24 months
Key findings
1. Advertising pays back
Key takeaway: Advertising is not just a cost. When planned and measured properly, it is a profitable business investment.
This study proves conclusively that advertising is a profitable driver of business growth. Put simply, advertising works.
All categories analysed in the study generated a positive payback from advertising. Advertising has an average short-term profit ROI of £1.87 per pound invested which increases to £4.11 when sustained effects are included.
Looking at short-term profit ROI, this chart shows the overall view by channel of profitability, mapping the spend (x axis) and the Profit ROI (y axis). Each channel is mapped using a bubble, with the size representing how much profit is driven. The chart is also split at a profit ROI of 1, anything above this line is considered profitable.
2. TV is the biggest driver of advertising-generated profit
Key takeaway: TV combines scale and profitability, making it the largest contributor to advertising-generated profit
In particular, TV (Linear and BVOD) has a very strong sustained effect, responsible for 54.7% of the full advertising-generated profit, with an average full profit ROI of £5.61 for every pound spent. Linear TV alone accounts for 46.6% of full advertising-generated profit, and an average full profit ROI of £5.94. By comparison, Online Video (which is mostly YouTube) has an average full profit ROI of £3.86 for every pound spent and accounts for 3.4% of full advertising-generated profit.
3. Linear TV has the highest weekly ‘saturation point’
Key takeaway: TV can absorb higher levels of profitable spend than other media because of its broad reach and ability to deliver scale.
Whilst it may seem intuitive to spend more in order to get more, it’s crucial to take into account diminishing returns.
As spend increases, the payback of each extra £1 of investment starts to reduce as diminishing returns kicks in. The scalability and diminishing returns profile vary channel to channel.
Diminishing returns also mean that scale and efficiency are inextricably linked; optimising towards one will impact the other. As a channel hits diminishing returns, the ROI gradually reduces. As each pound generates slightly less than the one before, the ROI ratio drops as spend increases, yet you drive more sales than would have been achieved at lower spend levels.
This ratio can be used to calculate the saturation point for each channel, which is the last point where every pound invested in a channel generates at least £1 profit.
Analysis shows that Linear TV has the highest saturation point. Essentially, advertisers can increase investment in Linear TV to a higher level than other media and it will continue to generate a profitable return.
Based on immediate payback (i.e. payback within one week of investment), Linear TV advertising on average hits saturation at £330,000 – nearly triple the equivalent scale of the next largest channel (Print) and over 8-times the scale of Online Video. This is no surprise, TV’s broad reach and its ability to drive scale helps deliver this result in contrast to typical digital channels like Paid Social and Online Display.
4. Immediate payback is not exclusive to ‘performance’ media
Key takeaway: Search is strong in immediate payback, but Linear TV is the second biggest driver of immediate profit. TV is not only a long-term brand channel; it also works quickly.
When looking at immediate payback (within one week) and the percentage of all advertising profit-driven, Generic PPC performs favourably, and accounts for the largest proportion of immediate payback (30.5%). Linear TV is the second biggest driver, accounting for 20.5%. This is followed by Paid Social (15.1%), Audio (8.6%) and BVOD (7.3%). This analysis shows how the immediate return is not exclusive to so-called ‘performance’ media, as channels like Linear TV and Audio also perform favourably.
5. Profitability varies by sector
Key takeaway: Sector context matters. Advertisers should use category benchmarks as a guide, not as a one-size-fits-all answer.
Whilst advertising generates a profitable return in all sectors, full Profit ROI varies greatly by sector.
For example, in the Automotive sector, advertising’s full Profit ROI is £4.65 per pound invested – more than double the Profit ROI in the Financial Services sector, where it is £1.95. Likewise, when looking at short-term profitability, advertising’s Profit ROI for Retail (large) was £3.15 per pound invested – nearly triple that of Travel (£1.19). The variance in ROIs is explained by nuances in the different business environments for each sector – such as the value of products, operating margins and the relative sensitivity of each category to the impact advertising has on sales.
6. Advertising effectiveness shifts post-Covid have been incremental
Key takeaway: The media landscape has changed, but the fundamentals of profitable advertising investment have remained = stable.
The Covid-19 pandemic was the defining event of recent years, reshaping both advertising and consumer spending. While some advertisers paused activity, others benefited from changing demand as household spending shifted from travel towards categories such as home improvement and broadband.
This analysis uses only the most recent media mix model for each advertiser. Where multiple studies were available, only the latest 52 weeks were included.
To compare pre- and post-pandemic performance, we analysed the 53 brands with like-for-like data across both periods: pre-Covid (studies ending between 2018 and Q1 2020) and post-Covid (2022–2023).
Across all channels, average advertising ROI declined by around 1% per year, indicating gradual change rather than disruption. As shown in the chart below, Generic PPC was one of the few channels to improve both ROI and investment, reflecting the growth of ecommerce and home working.
Within AV, Linear TV remains the largest profit driver (33.9%) despite lower spend and ROI. These reductions were partly offset by stronger returns from BVOD and Online Video, in line with changing viewing habits.
Paid social was the only channel to combine higher spend with lower ROI, suggesting investment has outpaced efficiency.
Overall, advertising effectiveness has evolved gradually since the pandemic, with shifts concentrated in individual channels rather than across the market as a whole.
In summary
‘Profit Ability 2: The new business case for advertising’ shows how advertising is a profitable driver of business growth. The study is vital in understanding the nuances of different channels and sectors. It can help build your case that advertising (for your sector) is money well spent, as well as provide the expected timescale of returns. It can help planners to right-size their media investment by channel and by timeframe.
And all its data helps fuel the Media Mix Navigator, the free tool that allows you to explore different planning scenarios to define the optimum media mix for your business. The tool can be used in a variety of situations, such as a starting point for budget allocation and payback when you don’t have access to specific econometrics; to show the impact on business outcomes of adding a new channel; or to explore the impact of different risk tolerances.
Industry perspective

Advertising is intangible capex, an investment and not a cost. This report provides the evidence that marketers need to prove the value of advertising to their CEOs, CFOs and Boards – and ultimately its value in supporting and strengthening their companies’ share prices.
Ian WhittakerManaging Director & Founder of Liberty Sky Advisors

Profit Ability 2 is recommended reading. It provides a much-needed helicopter view of advertising effectiveness, outlining how and why advertising works, and offers invaluable guidelines and benchmarks on typical roles and investment levels for different media channels.
Karen MartinChief Executive Officer, BBH London & Chair of the 2024 IPA Effectiveness Conference
How Profit Ability 2 is being used: The Growth Gap
Building on the econometric evidence behind Profit Ability 2, The Growth Gap is a new WPP Media study commissioned by Thinkbox that explores how much profitable growth brands may be leaving behind. Based on analysis of 624 brands and more than 7,400 campaign scenarios, it finds that the average brand could double its current advertising investment while keeping every additional pound profitable—potentially unlocking 11% more profit growth, equivalent to around £32 billion. The research also challenges the over-reliance on short-term “performance” channels such as social and search, showing that a better-balanced media mix can deliver stronger returns within the first year. Explore The Growth Gap to see how investment levels and channel choices could unlock additional profitable growth.
Use the data: Media Mix Navigator
The Profit Ability 2 databank also powers Thinkbox’s Media Mix Navigator, a free tool engineered by EssenceMediacom.
The Media Mix Navigator helps advertisers and planners explore different media investment scenarios, whether the objective is to drive increased profit or revenue. It models the first year of investment and the resulting “base” sales growth across the following two years.
Use it to explore:
- Recommended channel mix based on your brand and category.
- Different annual media spend levels.
- Different risk tolerances.
- Different time horizons: immediate, short-term and full-term.
- Profit Ability 2 benchmarks by category and channel.
The tool is designed to provide a robust starting point, not a guarantee. Individual advertisers should still consider factors such as seasonality, distribution, creative quality, fulfilment channels and their own econometric evidence where available.
Key takeaway: Profit Ability 2 gives the evidence; Media Mix Navigator helps turn that evidence into planning scenarios.
How advertisers and agencies should use this study
Profit Ability 2 can be used to help advertisers, media agencies, creative agencies and media owners in many ways:
- Proof that advertising works
- A better understanding of how advertising works
- Ad-generated profit benchmarks for individual categories
- Guidance on how long ad investment takes to pay back
- Benchmarks on the typical roles and investment levels for different media channels
- A view on how the ad effectiveness landscape has changed in recent years
- A conversation starter between advertisers and agencies on key decisions; i.e. channel selection, spend levels, attitudes to risk, timeframes for ad-driven returns.
FAQs
Profit Ability 2 is Thinkbox’s study of advertising profitability and payback. It is based on econometric analysis from 141 brands, £1.8bn of media spend, 10 media channels and 14 sectors (where 7 are reported individually), using data from 2021–2023.
Profit Ability 2 shows that advertising is a profitable business investment, that returns build over time, and that TV is the largest driver of full advertising-generated profit in the study.
Advertisers should use Profit Ability 2 to understand how media channels generate profit over different time horizons, compare channel ROI and profit contribution, and support better budget allocation decisions. It should be used as a benchmark alongside category knowledge, business objectives, creative quality and a brand’s own measurement data.
The Media Mix Navigator is powered by the Profit Ability 2 databank. It helps advertisers and planners explore different budget, channel mix, risk tolerance and time horizon scenarios using evidence from Profit Ability 2.
The Growth Gap is a WPP Media study commissioned by Thinkbox that builds on the Profit Ability 2 econometric database. It explores how much profit growth brands may be leaving behind by underinvesting or by deploying media budgets sub-optimally.
The analysis found that many brands are leaving an average of 11% of potential profit growth behind, equivalent to around £32 billion in profit. The opportunity varies by sector and depends on current spend levels and media mix.
Yes. Profit Ability 2 shows that advertising delivers positive profit payback when sustained effects are included. Across the study, average short-term profit ROI is £1.87 per £1 invested, rising to £4.11 when sustained effects are included.
Channels included in this study are:
| Audio | All forms of audio advertising including linear radio, digital radio and podcasts |
| BVOD | Video on Demand advertising on broadcaster platforms |
| Cinema | On screen advertising in cinemas |
| Generic PPC | Pay per click search advertising on non-branded keywords |
| Linear TV | Broadcast TV advertising |
| Online Display | All formats of display advertising |
| Online Video | All formats of online video pre/mid/post roll including YouTube |
| Out of Home | Digital and static posters in all environments |
| Paid Social | All advertising within social platforms including in-feed video |
| All advertising within newspapers & magazines. Digital spend with newsbrands etc. included in Online Display |
Direct mail, SEO, influencers are not included, as the data from the 141 brands did not have a robust volume of effectiveness data for these two channels. Similarly, brand search and affiliates are excluded, as these are considered pure ‘fulfilment’ media which facilitate a sale but do not generate demand for a brand.
The channels have been split out into as much detail as feasible from the dataset. The level of granularity was dictated by how channels were modelled during the data period (H2 2021 to 2023). During this period, the grouping / split of channels represents how channels were typically modelled.
In order to provide a robust benchmark at a sector level, a minimum threshold number of brands was set to ensure that a single brand isn’t skewing the sector learning. Whilst brands from 14 sectors are included in the study, there are only 7 sectors with enough sample to split them robustly from the overall aggregates. As a result, smaller sectors/advertisers (e.g. not for profit, B2B) are not included, but learnings can still be applied as well as provide a directional view.
Profit Ability 2 brings together media mix modelling analyses from brands targeting different audience segments. However, Profit Ability 2 / Media Mix Navigator is not designed to provide a target-audience-specific benchmark, as there are not enough brands targeting exactly the same audiences — or the same brands targeting different audiences — to make robust comparisons of the effectiveness and efficiency of different audience strategies.
Alongside factors such as category, budget and brand size, Media Mix Navigator incorporates an Appeal Factor, which is the closest proxy for target audience. This allows users to select between Niche and Mass audiences. However, Profit Ability 2 / Media Mix Navigator does not support further demographic audience splits.
Profit Ability 2 defines Profit ROI as profit contribution divided by media spend. The reported ROI is therefore based on media costs rather than total campaign costs. Creative production costs and some non-COGS variable costs may not be included, meaning the true break-even point could be slightly higher than the £1 ROI threshold.
The underlying data is based on the most recently available 52-week period for each brand. This does not mean that every channel was active for all 52 weeks. Active weeks vary by channel and advertiser — for example, Generic PPC can be active throughout the year, while TV may typically be used for shorter periods.
Profit Ability 2 provides evidence on the scalability and saturation points of different media channels, based on average databank response curves. However, due to data limitations, the published study does not provide a complete set of response curves for every channel and sector combination. Instead, Media Mix Navigator combines the average channel response curves with sector-level data, allowing it to estimate optimal investment levels and support channel-mix optimisation by sector.
Profit Ability 2 incorporates long-term multipliers to account for sustained advertising effects, with these estimates based on WPP benchmarks. Overall sector-level multipliers and overall channel-level multipliers are provided. However, a complete set of sector-by-channel multipliers is not published for every combination. Where a specific sector/channel multiplier is not available, the average databank channel multiplier hierarchy should be used, adjusted up or down based on the ratio of that sector’s long-term multiplier to the overall databank long-term multiplier.
Profit Ability 2 uses a profit-based definition of ROI, with profit contribution derived from factors such as unit sales, revenue contribution, profit margin and/or lifetime value. There are sector-to-sector differences in how this is calculated, which are detailed in the footnotes to the sector analysis. Profit Ability 2 therefore does not apply one standard profit margin across all sectors. The sector benchmarks should be understood as reflecting the underlying profit assumptions within the contributing media mix modelling analyses.
Profit Ability 2 shows that TV — Linear TV and BVOD combined — generates the largest share of full advertising-generated profit in the study. TV accounts for 54.7% of full advertising-generated profit, with an average full profit ROI of £5.61 per £1 spent.
Immediate payback is the contribution of advertising in the same week as the advertising. Carryover payback is the contribution of advertising within 13 weeks of the advertising. Sustained payback is the contribution of advertising from week 14 onwards (generally within two years of the advertising.)
Short – term payback is up to 13 weeks (the combination of immediate and carryover), whilst full payback is up to two years (short-term + sustained).
TV matters because it combines scale, profitability and long-term payback. Profit Ability 2 shows that TV drives the largest share of full advertising-generated profit, while also contributing significantly to immediate payback.
A saturation point is the level of spend where each additional £1 invested still generates at least £1 of profit. Above that point, extra spend may still generate sales, but it no longer produces at least £1 of profit.
In Profit Ability 2, Linear TV has the highest saturation point. Based on immediate payback, Linear TV hits saturation at around £330,000 per week on average.
Downloads & related resources
- Download the full Profit Ability 2: The new business case for advertising report
- Watch the Profit Ability 2 launch on demand
- Use the Media Mix Navigator
- Watch The Growth Gap
- The Growth Gap press release
Awards and recognition
| Award | Status | Category | Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| MRG Awards | Highly Commended | Best Research Initiative | 2025 |
| MRG Awards | Winner | Best Trade/Industry Body Research | 2025 |
| MRG Awards | Nominated | Best Realisation of Research | 2025 |
| MRG Awards | Highly Commended | Best Research Collaboration | 2025 |
| MRG Awards | Winner | Excellence in Media Effectiveness | 2025 |
| Media Week Awards | Winner (Silver) | Media Brand of the Year | 2025 |
| Adwanted Media Research Awards | Winner | Best Custom Media Research Project — Trade Body | 2025 |
| Adwanted Media Research Awards | Nominated | The Adrian Edwards Award for Best Use of Datasets | 2025 |
| MRS Awards | Winner | Application of Analytics | 2024 |
| Media Week Awards | Winner (Gold) | Trade Body Research | 2024 |
Read about this study in the press
- Campaign - Advertising generates most profit after first 13 weeks of a campaign
- Marketing Week – Advertising’s longer term ROI more than double short term, study finds
- The Media Leader - Advertising generates profit, but not all media channels are equal
- Marketing Beat - Thinkbox study proves ‘all advertising works’, with TV driving most profit
- WARC – 58% of advertising profitability occurs after the first three months
- The Telegraph - YouTube adverts far less valuable than traditional TV, broadcasters claim
- Digiday - CMOs at Cannes: Tackling their evolving role amid AI and growth challenges
- Nick Manning - Who cares wins: The antidote to 'badvertising'
- Dr. Grace Kite – Think of your media mix like ‘Moneyball’ if you want to find success
- Shauna Lewis - Agencies caution advertisers against knee-jerk response to rise of social media
Thinkbox
