- Home
- TV Effectiveness
- TV at a Glance
- TV Technology
- TV Planning
- TV Toolbox
- Getting Started on TV
- TV Ad Galleries
- The Thinkboxes
- Research
- Case Studies
- Nickable Stuff
- Events and Training
- Hot Topics
- Press Office
- About Us
Digital Television Recorders (DTRs / PVRs)
If TV viewers want to avoid ads, they can. It's never been easier because now they have the most intuitive and easy-to-use technology to avoid them: digital television recorder (DTR) devices, such as the Sky+ box.
The DTR's arrival sent a ripple of fear through the TV advertising industry. It assumed that, given the choice, consumers would skip ads. However, we've now got plenty of robust data to tell us what's really going on, and evidence from BARB, ACB/LBS & SkyView all paint the same sort of picture: rather than avoiding ads, most DTR homes actually watch more at normal speed.
People don't get DTRs to avoid ads; they get them to find content they want to watch. Owners are not militant anti-commercial ad avoiders. According to the latest Skyview panel data (which accurately measures viewing patterns in Sky homes), 83% of viewing in a DTR home is to ‘live’ TV and viewing increases by 15% when homes acquire one. As for ad breaks, even in the 17% of viewing that is time-shifted, viewers with a DTR still watch 30% of ad breaks at normal speed producing a net increase of 3% for ads viewed at normal speed.
According to BARB, total time-shifted viewing represents just 6% of total UK.
BARB’s figures also show that nearly 80% of all time-shifted viewing is watched within 7 days of recording, with 37.2% of content being viewed on the same day. Only the viewing of ads and programmes within 7 days is counted within BARB’s published data; the remaining 20% is effectively free to advertisers.
People who get one of these start watching more TV partly because when many upgrade from the Sky box to a Sky+ box, the original goes to another room in the house - so in the bedroom they start watching more commercial TV because they've now got more channels - but also because the technology builds their relationship with television and allows them to indulge their interests more, on their own terms.
The fact that 83 per cent of the viewing in DTR households is still to live broadcasting gives us massive confidence in the importance of linear television in the future. So even though you've got this technology, that could allow you to completely self-schedule your evening's viewing, you only use it for 18 per cent of your viewing. In fact that number is coming down and down all the time as penetration of these boxes increases.
Interestingly, most time-shifted programmes are watched on same day as recording.
Of course some people do fast-forward through ad breaks, but not all of the time. Perhaps speed watching" is a more appropriate phrase than "fast-forwarding" as demonstrated by Thinkbox's engagement study, which filmed people watching television in their homes. We witnessed extraordinary levels of concentration on the screen amongst those with their thumbs on the accelerator. And Duckfoot Research & Development established that as long as you've already seen a TV ad once, your recall of this ad when seen at 30 times faster than normal is about 65 per cent of the level that it would otherwise have been at normal speed. So, for advertisers, speed-watching" has real value - and, it comes free!
Thinkbox decided to take this body of research to the next step by examining hitherto ignored aspects of ownership: emotional context, motivations, the benefits, relationship with TV and advertising, engagement and quality control. The relationship that emerged between owners and their DTRs is one that advertisers (and fundamentalist nay-sayers) can genuinely learn from.
Work Research was commissioned to undertake in-depth, qualitative research during September 2007 of owners of a mix of DTR brands with differing lengths of ownership. Research also included data from viewing diaries and hard-drive exploration. It revealed DTR owners get more out of their TV and have an enlightened, positive view of TV advertising. DTRs provide a sense of quality control that creates a "give and take" relationship with ads. Fast-forwarding ads happens but not every time and is more prevalent when breaks are longer and/or ads are perceived as worse.
DTR viewers engage with ads when they fast-forward through them. The concentration needed to fast forward means it is more appropriate to call it "speed-watching". Sponsorship bumpers are recalled and seen as useful navigational tools when speed-watching.
Ads are also spotted and rewound to watch fully. Thinkbox found there was a greater appreciation of good ads and of the timeliness of some advertising, especially on live TV: for example retail sales, films and trailers. DTRs renew their owners' interest in the relevance of advertising.
There will always be a minority who wish for an ad-free media world but the research showed DTR owners were more circumspect. Many acknowledged advertising's funding role and rejected the notion of paying more for ad-free TV.
DTR owners were also very positive towards the new advertising technologies. Green button advertising (pressing green during an ad to add an extended version to the planner) was seen as useful, in the same way as recording programmes is seen as useful, as it offers the convenience of watching at a more expedient time. They were also warm to the relevance of a "pull" advertising model, which extends the control benefit of a DTR to advertising. Most anticipated increased richness, longer copy ads, more detail, greater relevance and more comparisons.
The research showed DTRs also helped promote domestic harmony. In multi-person households, TV viewing requires a degree of compromise; however DTRs let people record now and watch later. In couples, Thinkbox found that there is an element of "gifting" programmes to partners - recording things they think the other would enjoy. DTRs can bring viewers together rather than fragmenting viewing within the household.
It is also easier for viewers to engage and be loyal to programmes they like with a DTR. For existing series it removes some stresses and strains, including the need to be "there", the pressure of seeing every episode, the disappointment of missing out and the inconvenience of setting the VHS. For new series it prevents accidental dropping and encourages long-term sticking with a series, especially to longer-run series that require real commitment in busy lives.
Rationally, DTRs allow for indulgence of personal tastes and occasional over-indulgence - for example, using the series link feature and bingeing on a favourite programme. Emotionally, they can be liberating - enabling viewers to watch favourite programmes while other household members are away - and provide a deeper level of gratification, a heightened sense of specialness and indulgence.
DTRs encourage a more engaged attitude to selecting programming. More planning requires more thought and our research highlighted significantly higher levels of interest and response to trailers. This engagement even bleeds into partners' viewing.
DTRs also increase value perceptions: they soften resentment of subscription fees. Consequently, respondents in the research would say things like "it [the DTR] is the best thing since sliced bread".
Ultimately, the research showed that, when people have access to the "me-TV" of a DTR, they will still go to the schedules as their first point of call. There will probably be no signs of a desire to avoid TV ads, so long as broadcasters manage the flow and quality of the advertising.